Hard to pull something off of there, but any hit by Colon. Insanely fun plays but not clutch enough to be listed: Escobar inside the park, Butler steals 2nd, and Moose foul catch.
The thing about the WC game is that there are 4 or 5 moments that should be top 20. I can't think of another game like that. I wouldn't be able to pinpoint a play, but Finnegan's performance there should somehow be recognized.